Fence blown down between two gardens: who pays, and what happens next
The Met Office named Storm Austen and Storm Boelo in October 2026. When a storm like these brings down the fence between two gardens, the first question is whose fence it is. Kane fixes broken fences and fits new runs across south London.
First, make it safe and keep a record
Keep children, pets and cars away from any panel that is still leaning, because the next gust can bring it down. Do not climb the fence or lean on it to see next door's side.
Before anything is moved, take photos from your side: the whole run, then each post at ground level, then anything the fence hit. Note the date. If you claim on insurance and it goes to the Financial Ombudsman Service, it says it needs to be sure there were storm conditions “where you live when the damage happened”, and it takes official weather reports into account. A dated record made on the day is the start of that.
Whose fence is it?
HM Land Registry is plain about the two things most people go by. There is no rule that the fence on the left or right of a property belongs to that property owner, and which side the posts and rails are on “is not a reliable guide either.” GOV.UK adds that there is usually no record of who owns the fence between two properties, and most title plans do not show exact boundaries.
The answer, if there is one, is in the paperwork. Land Registry says a deed may include a covenant, a legally binding promise, to maintain a fence, which shows who maintains it but does not always mean they own it. Some deed plans show T marks. Land Registry says a T on your side of the line generally means you own and maintain that fence, and two T marks back to back (an H) indicate a shared boundary, meaning both neighbours share upkeep costs. The marks are not always conclusive, so check the wording in the deed too. Your title register, deeds or papers from your solicitor are the place to look, and next door's may say something yours does not.
If the deeds do not settle it, agree with next door who pays for what before anything is ordered. Land Registry's own advice is to speak to your neighbour first before changing a fence.
If it is next door's fence and they will not act
Speak to them first. Then put it in writing: a short message with the date, what came down and a photo. Keep a copy, and keep your photos. If the house next door is let, ask the tenant to pass the message to whoever manages it.
Be realistic about what that can achieve. Home Owners Alliance says that unless the fence is a safety hazard, there is very little you can do to force a neighbour to repair or replace it.
If you still cannot agree, Land Registry says to “try to agree a practical solution before taking formal action”, and that mediation may help you avoid court or tribunal proceedings, which can be very costly. This guide is not legal advice, and a boundary dispute that goes that far needs proper advice of its own.
Will insurance pay?
Often not for a fence on its own, and your policy wording decides. Home Owners Alliance says policies often exclude storm damage to fences, hedges and gates. Ombudsman decisions show the same pattern. One, from 2021, describes fences as excluded “as they commonly are in most property insurance policies”. In another, the policy covered a storm-damaged fence only where the home was “damaged at the same time and by the same cause”.
Where a policy does cover the fence and the insurer turns the claim down, the ombudsman asks three questions:
- Was there a storm on the date the damage happened?
- Does the damage look like what the ombudsman generally sees as storm damage?
- Were storm conditions the main cause of the damage, or did other factors mean the damage might have happened anyway?
Some insurers say only winds above a certain point on the Beaufort scale count as storm-force winds. The ombudsman says the Beaufort scale is not the only thing it will look at. If an insurer relies on an exclusion, the insurer has to prove that the exclusion applies, for example with an inspection report.
Look hard at the posts before you claim. If they had already rotted at the base, an insurer could treat that as the other factor in the third question. Jacksons Fencing names rotten posts as the most common reason panels fall over in high winds. To see where yours failed, use our guide to broken and rotten fence posts.
If your insurer turns the claim down, complain to it first. For most complaints it has 8 weeks to send a final response. If you are unhappy with that response, or get none, you can take it to the Financial Ombudsman Service.
Can it go back as it was?
Usually, yes. Planning Portal says you do not need planning permission to alter, maintain, improve or take down an existing fence in England if it is no more than 1 metre high next to a road used by vehicles, or its footpath, and no more than 2 metres high elsewhere. If an existing fence is already over those limits, the same page says it can go back without permission only if its height is not increased. There are exceptions. A listed property, an Article 4 direction or a planning condition can remove that right, and in a conservation area taking a fence down might need permission.
Repair or a new run?
That depends on the posts. If one or two timber posts snapped or rotted at ground level and the rest of the run is firm, a repair may be enough, and the fence post guide matches each kind of break to a fix, concrete posts included. If several posts went over in one run, the close-board guide explains what decides when a whole run is due.
What it costs and what happens next
Kane does not publish a price list, and every quote is free. For a fence that came down between two gardens, the figure turns on:
- how many posts snapped or rotted through
- whether a post can take a repair spur or needs replacing
- whether old concrete has to be dug out
- how easy it is to reach the fence line, from your side or next door's
- whether the panels or boards that came down can go back up
Agree with next door who is arranging it. Ask them for access before Steven visits, because the posts may need to be reached from both sides. Then WhatsApp Steven photos of the whole run and of each post at ground level, or call him. Steven visits every job himself, and the quote is free. If you and next door are sharing the cost, one quote for the whole run means you both see the same figure.
How soon it goes back up depends on the two households more than on the fence. Work can be booked once you and next door agree who is arranging it, and once your insurer has answered if you are claiming. From the photos, Steven can say whether it looks like a repair or a new run. He then visits to see the run and gives a free quote.
Kane is based in Mitcham and works across Surrey and south London, with local pages for fencing in Mitcham, fence work in Croydon, Tooting and Wandsworth, among others.
Two of Kane's TrustATrader reviews are about fixing fences, not only fitting new ones. In November 2025 Tom wrote: “Very responsive and competent work replacing a fence post. Have used Steven and team before, and would do again.” In April 2026 Zoe wrote that Steven did “a fantastic job of replacing and fixing some broken fencing” in her garden. The rest are on the reviews page.
Common questions
My neighbour's fence blew down into my garden. Do I have to fix it?
Not because it landed on your side. Which way a fence fell does not decide whose it is, and the side the posts are on is not a reliable guide; the deeds may say more. Tell your neighbour, keep dated photos, and agree who is arranging the repair before anyone books it.
Do we have to split the cost of a shared fence?
Check both sets of deeds first. Land Registry says two T marks back to back on the plan (an H) indicate a shared boundary, meaning both neighbours share upkeep costs, and a T on your side of the line generally means you own and maintain that fence. The marks are not always conclusive, so check the wording in the deed too. If the deeds do not settle it, agree with next door who pays for what.
Will my insurer pay for a fence that blew down between two gardens?
Often not. Many policies exclude fences, and in one ombudsman decision the policy covered a storm-damaged fence only if the home was damaged at the same time by the same cause. Read your own policy wording. If a claim is refused, complain to the insurer first, then to the Financial Ombudsman Service if you are unhappy with the answer.
Can we put the fence back higher this time?
Only within Planning Portal's limits without permission: 2 metres from ground level, or 1 metre next to a road used by vehicles or its footpath, unless the property or the neighbour's is listed, or an Article 4 direction or planning condition removes the right. If the new fence would not meet those conditions, Planning Portal says you will need to apply for planning permission.
Sources
- Met Office, UK Storm Centre
- HM Land Registry, boundaries and boundary disputes
- GOV.UK, your property boundaries
- Financial Ombudsman, storm damage, home insurance complaints, and decisions DRN-2834716 and DRN-3753383
- Home Owners Alliance, how do I repair storm damage to my house
- Jacksons Fencing, reasons your fence is storm damaged (November 2020)
- Planning Portal, fences, gates and garden walls
If your fence is down or leaning, WhatsApp Steven a photo of the run and the posts, or call him on 07448 176937. Steven can then say whether it looks like a repair or a new run, and quote for free across Surrey and south London.
WhatsApp Steven a photo